-
Evangelising the Laity for Mission
Talk Five: Barriers to Evangelisation
Fr Pat Collins, C.M.
7th Oct 2026
In this talk, I would like to draw attention to some impediments to the new evangelisation. The list is not intended to be in any way exhaustive, and the topics are not listed in any order of importance.
1] Universalism
The scriptures give the impression that perhaps only a minority of people will be saved. Here are a few examples.
· In Mt 7:13-14 Jesus said, "Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it. But small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it.”
· St. Peter stated that, “It is difficult for good people to be saved; what, then, will become of godless sinners?” (1 Pt 4:18).
In spite of these scripture texts, many of our contemporaries believe that the road that leads to heaven is wide and that most people take it, with the possible exception of some extraordinarily evil people. Many priests seem to agree with this point of view and in their preaching when they avoid mentioning the possibility of forfeiting salvation and having to endure eternal separation from God. The late Cardinal Avery Dulles wrote,
"The mass for the dead has turned into a Mass of the Resurrection, which sometimes seems to celebrate not so much the resurrection of the Lord as the salvation of the deceased, without any reference to sin and punishment. More education is needed to convince people that they ought to fear God, who as Jesus taught, can punish soul and body together in hell (cf. Mt 10:28)."
If people think that we are saved no matter what we believe or how we behave, it is not surprising that evangelisation, and the demands of Christian discipleship don't make much impression.
2] Relativism
Secular culture is said to be postmodern in nature. This world view maintains that, rather than being an objective fact, all our knowledge of truth is subjective and at best partial and provisional. Pope John Paul II described it in par. 91 of Faith & Reason in these words,
“The currents of thought which claim to be postmodern merit appropriate attention. According to some of them, the time of certainties is irrevocably past, and the human being must now learn to live in a horizon of total absence of meaning, where everything is provisional and ephemeral.”
Postmodernist relativism poses a very real challenge as far as evangelisation is concerned.
Christians believe that God has revealed absolute truth in and through the person and teachings of Jesus Christ and that he is the sole mediator between God and human beings (cf. 1 Tim 2:5). As scripture asserts, there is no other name by which people can be saved (cf. Acts 4:12). However, people in postmodern culture, including some liberal Catholics, find those claims very hard to accept. They tend to see Jesus as merely one outstanding religious leader among many others such as Buddha, Lau Tzu, Zoroaster and Mohammed. Any claim that Christ is unique and the sole means of salvation is considered to be arrogant, intolerant and unjustified. They consider all religions as equally valid paths to transcendence.
Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI said on Oct 23rd 2014,
" According to this way of thinking, it is usually taken for granted that different religions are variants of one and the same reality . . . This renunciation of truth seems realistic and useful for peace among religions in the world. It is nevertheless lethal to faith."
While many people in Western countries have parted company with institutional forms of religion, they will often say that they are spiritual. People who identify as “Spiritual but Not Religious” believe that there is a spiritual dimension to life, and many accept that there is a divine being, but reject religious dogmas and doctrines. So, they often resist the claims of Christian evangelisers.
3] Preaching forgiveness to people with no sense of sin
An essential aspect of the gospel message is the fact that Jesus died so that sin could be forgiven and people would thereby be reconciled to God. But what does one do in a culture where many people have lost their sense of God, and sin as an offence against God? Pope St John Paul II said,
“It happens not infrequently in history, for more or less lengthy periods and under the influence of many different factors, that the moral conscience of many people becomes seriously clouded . . . It is inevitable therefore that in this situation there is an obscuring also of the sense of sin . . . This explains why my predecessor Pius XII one day declared, in words that have almost become proverbial, ‘The sin of the century is the loss of the ‘sense of sin.”
4] The problem of scandal
The problem with the Church is that many of its members do not practice what they preach. There is nothing new about this. For example, in the Second Letter of Clement (A.D. 100 approx.) the anonymous author said that it was not too surprising that the name of the Lord was blasphemed by the pagans.
“For when the pagans hear from our mouths the words of God, they marvel at their beauty and greatness. But when they discover that our actions are not worthy of the words we speak, they turn from wonder to blasphemy, saying that it is a myth and a delusion. For when they hear from us that God says, “It is no credit to you if you love those who love you, but it is a credit to you if you love your enemies and those who hate you,” when they hear these things, they marvel at such extraordinary goodness. But, when they see that we do not only fail to love those who hate us we even fail to love those who love us, they scornfully laugh at us, and the Name is blasphemed."
Is it any different nowadays? Divisions in and between the churches rob the Gospel message of its credibility. As Pope Francis has observed in par of The Joy of the Gospel,
"The credibility of the Christian message would be much greater if Christians could overcome their divisions and the Church could realize the fullness of catholicity proper to her."
Of course, another cause of scandal, in a number of countries, is the vile phenomenon of child sex abuse by priests and religious. It is clear in Ireland that the virtual collapse of the Church's influence, together with a big decline in church attendance, and lack of priestly vocations is due to this scandal. Is it any wonder that many nominal Christians think that, instead of being a way of salvation Catholicism is a sickness that mistakes itself for a cure.
5] Secular versus Christian sexual ethics
Sexual morality of a secular kind generally begins with human autonomy and consent as the highest goods, while Christian sexual morality begins with God’s purpose for the human person and the body. The two frameworks often overlap in valuing dignity and avoiding harm, but they diverge sharply on the meaning, purpose, and boundaries of sexual expression. They differ greatly when it comes to such sexual issues as cohabitation, pornography, contraception, gay sex, abortion, and whether gender is biologically determined or a matter of personal choice. Implicit in resistance to the good news of the Gospel is often a conscious or unconscious reluctance to change one’s sexual values and behaviours from those of the secular world to those of Christianity.
6] The Role of the Evil One
The New Testament says that one reason that evangelisation is not always successful is the malign role of the devil. In 2 Cor 4:4 St. Paul made the following dramatic observation,
“The god of this age [i.e. Satan] has blinded the minds of unbelievers, so that they cannot see the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ, who is the image of God.”
Would be evangelists are naive if they do not acknowledge that there is a demonic power opposed to their evangelistic work, one who acts through illusions, false inspirations, prejudices, lies and the exploitation of the issues already mentioned.
Conclusion
Recently, when I said in prayer, “Speak, Lord your servant is listening,” I was led to Jer 2:13, which says,
“My people have committed two sins: they have turned away from me, the spring of fresh water, and they have dug cisterns, cracked cisterns that can hold no water at all.”
This is a very good biblical description of the effects of the six obstacles we have examined. Many of our contemporaries have abandoned God, who is the source of life, and have tried to build their own unreliable secular systems in order to satisfy their human needs, the latest of which is AI. Like cracked, leaky cisterns, the promise of purely secular forms of satisfaction will fail to satisfy the needs of those who rely on them. For some, the forgetfulness of God will lead to a kind of hidden despair which says,
“Eat and drink, for tomorrow we die” (Is 22:13; 1 Cor 15:32) because they are “Without God and without hope in the world” (Eph 2:12)
while other disillusioned people will consciously or unconsciously say,
“Seek the Lord while you can find him. Call on him now while he is near” (Is 55:6).
That is the time when many people will be open to the Gospel message. Next week we will look at some means of overcoming the obstacles to the kerygma.