-
Fr Pat Collins C.M.
Empowering the Laity for Mission
Talk Six: Overcoming obstacles to evangelisation
14 Oct 2026
Introduction
In the last input, we looked at six obstacles to the effective proclamation of the Christian gospel. In this one, I want to briefly propose possible ways of overcoming them. I found this was the hardest talk to write, and you may find it a difficult one to understand. That said, I hope that it contains some helpful observations.
1] Countering universalism
Those who espouse universalist views believe that the road to heaven is wide and most people take it. They either deny that hell exists or downplay the possibility of going to it, no matter what people believe or do in the course of their lives. The bible and the Church warn that the road to perdition is wide, and many take it. For example, in one of his parables, Jesus described how, “the king said to the servants, Bind him hand and foot, and cast him out into the outer darkness; there will be wailing and gnashing of teeth. For many are called, but few are chosen” (Mt 22:13-14).
In a recent book, I included a chapter entitled, “Near-death experiences and apologetics.” In it, I noted the fact that not all those who undergo clinical death have a positive experience. The Handbook of Near-Death Experiences reports that twelve different studies involving 1,369 subjects found that 23% ‘reported NDEs ranging from disturbing to terrifying or despairing.’ For example, Dr Bruce Greyson recounts Brenda’s experience. She had an NDE as a result of attempted suicide. In part of her account, she talked about slipping down into a cave that was grey and brown in colour. Then she went on to recount, “I heard cries, wails, moans and gnashing of teeth. I saw these beings that resembled humans, with the shape of a head and body, but they were ugly and grotesque. I remember colours like red, green, and purple, but can’t positively remember if these were the colours of these beings. They were frightening and sounded like they were tormented, in agony. No one spoke to me.”
Rather than presenting a single, uniform vision of damnation, NDEs of a hellish kind generally fall into two distinct categories. Firstly, there is an experience of the void as falling into an absolute, vast nothingness, a pitch-black tunnel, or complete isolation. This state is defined by a terrifying absence of light, love, or external reality—leading to severe existential anxiety. Secondly, there is the vision of a hellish landscape that is similar to classical religious frameworks. Witnesses describe landscapes of intense heat or fire, overwhelming darkness, agonising torment, and malevolent or disfigured entities. It seems to me that evangelists can refer to this kind of empirical evidence tends to undermine the beliefs of those who espouse a universalist notion of salvation.
2] Critique of the relativist point of view
Relativists believe that truth is in the eye of the beholder and that we cannot know any absolute, objective and reliable verity. Ironically, this statement is itself an assertion of an absolute truth, which seems therefore to be self-contradictory.
You may recall that in the second input of this course we referred to the view of St Thomas who said that the truths taught with confidence by Christians are utterly reliable because they are revealed by God, who neither deceives nor can be deceived. However, as St Thomas Aquinas maintained, we can only validate a claim to speak supernatural, revealed truth by performing supernatural deeds of power which are only made possible by divine intervention. Surely Jesus declared as much on more than one occasion. For example, in Jn 10:38 he said, “Even though you do not believe me, you should at least believe my deeds, in order that you may know once and for all that the Father is in me and that I am in the Father”
3] How does one evangelise those with no sense of sin?
Recently I asked ChatGPT the following question: “How does one get the gospel message of the forgiveness of sin across to people with little or no sense of sin?” It answered, “To communicate the gospel of forgiveness to people with little or no sense of sin, you must shift the starting point of the conversation from legal guilt to relational and existential brokenness.” I think that this is a good and relevant answer. So where can we start the conversation? I would like to suggest that evangelisers should begin by focusing on the two interrelated issues of meaning & belonging.
A] The search for meaning
In his book The Courage to Be, Paul Tillich argued that human existence is perpetually threatened by "non-existence," which manifests itself psychologically as existential anxiety. Tillich asserted that
In classical Greco-Roman times, people were anxious about the prospect of mortality and non-existence.
In the Middle Ages, people were anxious about guilt and condemnation
In our modern post-truth era, people are anxious about the absence of meaning & purpose.
In the 20th century, psychologists discussed the question: what is the deepest human need? Freud said it was pleasure, Adler said it was power, Maslow said it was self-actualisation. While there is some truth in all these answers, I think that Viktor Frankl got to the heart of the matter when he suggested that the deepest human need is a sense of meaning and purpose. Frankl argued that when a person's will to meaning is frustrated or unfulfilled, it results in an existential vacuum—a deep feeling of emptiness and boredom that often manifests as aggression, addiction, or depression. There is a saying which states, “one needs to scratch where people itch.” As has already been suggested, modern people are no longer itching with guilt and a fear of condemnation, but they do itch when it comes to the question of the meaning of life. As Pope Francis has written in par 165 of Evangelii Gaudium, “The Kerygma is the message capable of responding to the desire for the infinite which abides in every human heart.”
Because he was aware of this fact, Anglican priest Nicky Gumbel focused the Alpha course on the meaning of life, specifically through the inaugural talk entitled "Is There More to Life Than This?"—because he recognised that meaning is a key issue for people in the modern secular world. So, instead of giving a traditional evangelistic talk about legal guilt or fear of judgment, Gumbel purposefully draws attention to the negative consequences of living in a post-truth culture. Instead of talking about doctrinal or ethical truths, Alpha focuses on Jesus as the living embodiment of truth and meaning.
A] Belonging as a basic need
Nicky Gumbel also has another insight which is well worth mentioning. He points out that the traditional evangelistic approach focused on the three B’s of right belief, right behaviour, and a consequent sense of belonging. He maintains that in our society where community is often absent, a sense of belonging and non-judgmental acceptance is a primary need. This insight lies at the heart of the pastoral approach of Alpha. Their meetings usually begin with a meal, which helps to form bonds of friendship and belonging. As Gumbel says, “People will come to meetings for many reasons, but they will stay for only one - friendship. People aren't looking for a friendly church; they're looking for a church where they can make friends." It is within this loving context that those conducting an Alpha Course talk about experiencing the length and breadth, the height and depth, of the love of Christ as a result of being baptised in the Holy Spirit.
Just as sunlight coming through a kitchen window reveals the presence of dust on windowsills and tabletops, so the light of the love of Jesus reveals a person’s own lack of love, i.e., their sinfulness. As a result, those who have been enlightened by God’s love will have a choice to make, i.e., whether to regret their sins and to behave in a more loving way or not. So, one doesn’t have to repent of sin as a condition of receiving God’s love; rather, one becomes aware of sin and repents of it as a consequence of receiving God’s unconditional merciful-love as an unmerited gift. As St Paul says in Eph 2:8-9, “For it is by God’s grace that you have been saved through faith. It is not the result of your own efforts, but God’s gift, so that no one can boast about it.” That is why the first assertion of the kerygma is, “God loves you,” and not, “You are a sinner in need of forgiveness.”
B] Belonging as a basic need
Nicky Gumbel also has another insight which is well worth mentioning. He points out that the traditional evangelistic approach focuses on the three B’s of right belief, right behaviour, and a consequent sense of belonging. He maintains that in our society where community is often absent, a sense of belonging and non-judgmental acceptance is a primary need. This insight lies at the heart of the pastoral approach of Alpha. Their meetings usually begin with a meal, which helps to form bonds of friendship and belonging. As Gumbel says, “People will come to meetings for many reasons, but they will stay for only one - friendship. People aren't looking for a friendly church; they're looking for a church where they can make friends." It is within this loving context that those conducting an Alpha Course talk about experiencing the length and breadth, the height and depth, of the love of Christ as a result of being baptised in the Holy Spirit.
Just as sunlight coming through a kitchen window reveals the presence of dust on windowsills and tabletops, so the light of the love of Jesus reveals a person’s own lack of love, i.e., their sinfulness. As a result, those who have been enlightened by God’s love will have a choice to make, i.e., whether to regret their sins and to behave in a more loving way or not. So, one doesn’t have to repent of sin as a condition of receiving God’s love; rather, one becomes aware of sin and repents of it as a consequence of receiving God’s unconditional love as an unmerited gift. As St Paul says in Eph 2:8-9, “For it is by God’s grace that you have been saved through faith. It is not the result of your own efforts, but God’s gift, so that no one can boast about it.” That is why the first assertion of the kerygma is, “God loves you,” and not, “You are a sinner in need of forgiveness.”
4] Counteracting scandal by witness
We will not dwell on this point. Clearly, the Church needs to repent in a public and private way for its many failings. Where sexual sin against children and vulnerable people has taken place, rigorous safeguarding measures need to be put in place, pastoral help offered, and compensation paid. Furthermore, the church needs saintly people to witness to the beauty of the gospel by leading lives devoted to the spiritual and corporal works of mercy as well as action for justice on behalf of those members of society who are poor, marginalised and oppressed. As Pope Francis said, “A person is a credible witness if there is harmony between what he believes and how he lives. Many Christians only say they believe but live something else … and this is hypocrisy.”
5] Responding to those who are sexually permissive
What was said about the three B’s is relevant here. Instead of focusing on sexual ethics, focus instead on the love of Jesus and discipleship. Within that context, sexual issues can be discussed. Pure in Heart is a Catholic organisation for young adults who promote the notion of chastity. One of its members explained, “We always begin with the positive, explaining that sex is a good thing and that this is good news. So, we look at the meaning of sex and affirm that desire is good and natural, but it is something we need to order and orientate for and toward our own happiness and our own good. The central message is about love – chastity is about a deeper understanding of living out the desire to love and God’s love for us. Most Catholics think the Church says a big ‘no’ to sex, but in fact it is a big ‘yes’ to a higher form of love. Everyone wants love, so this is a way of how to achieve it.”
6] Tearing down the strongholds of the evil one
Because this is an important topic, next week’s input will be devoted to it.
Conclusion
In Mt 12:36-37 Jesus said, “I tell you, on the day of judgment people will give account for every careless word they speak, for by your words you will be justified, and by your words you will be condemned.” Commenting on the reference to careless words in Matthew, Cardinal Raniero Cantalamessa has written, “They are the empty, fruitless, purely human words spoken by those whose duty it is to proclaim the living, life-changing words of God . . . They are the idle words of false prophets, that is, the words of those who want us to believe that they speak to us in God’s name, but in fact are simply putting forward their own ideas. They do not draw what they say from the heart of God but merely think it up themselves. The wonderful promises of Scripture to do with the efficacy of God’s word do not apply where careless, sterile, unproductive words are concerned.” However, as 1 Pt 4:11 says, “If anyone speaks, they should do so as one who speaks the very words of God.” Evangelisers can only do that if they are living holy lives, praying the Scriptures and focusing on the person, word and will of the Lord. If they do this, their words will be efficacious in spite of obstacles. Like Samuel of old, they will find that their “words do not fall to the ground” (1 Sam 3:19). In other words, they will prove to be effective in spite of obstacles.